never ever throw the things you want just to impress a woman- many women dont like mainstream music. i dont like alternative that much its too over rated, plus we women will not get turned off just because you love air supply, its actually sweet that you love classics, its something else to look forward too, you have your tastes, dont mind others, if you like jim brickman and chicago you must really be a sensitive guy, it could be a plus points for you.
for me i love reggae, ska, punk, jazz, rnb , any type of song and rhythm that could describe me
instead of putting those away find someone like you who can enjoy a relaxing music, find a woman who can understand and enjoy the same music with you
and do explore other music too, try reggae, its also very relaxing
singers like bob marley, sublime, peace pipe, and try other musicians and artist
you dont need to store those precious cd's away, have confidence!